Detailed View

Export the results of this page in detailed view as PDF
V. Foreign Higher Education and Education Systems, International Relations, Bilateral Relations
B. Essays, Commentaries, Statements
Author BOUGNOL, Marie-Laure (DULA, Jose H.)
Title Technical pitfalls in university rankings / Marie-Laure Bouhgnol ; Jose H. Dulá
Publication year 2015
Source/Footnote In: Higher education. - 69 (2015) 5, S. 859 - 866
Inventory number 38268
Keywords Ausland : USA : einzelne Hochschulen ; Hochschule : Wettbewerb
Abstract Academicians, experts, and other stakeholders have contributed extensively to the literature on university rankings also known as ?league tables?. Often the tone is critical usually focused on the subjective aspects of the process; e.g., the list of the universities? attributes used in the rankings, their respective weights, and the size and composition of the comparison group. These aspects of a ranking are an easy target since, after all, they are based on someone?s opinion even if this person is considered an expert. There are other, purely technical, reasons why ranking schemes are problematic. In this paper we discuss these aspects of rankings by studying the handling of the data, exposing logical mistakes, and raising interpretation issues. We present these as a list of four ?pitfalls? invoking in each case an example from an actual rankings. Each case also results in recommendations that address the technical issues involved.(HRK / Abstract übernommen) Bougnol, Marie-Laure, E-Mail: mbougno@ju.edu